Julian Alvarez: Dip in Form or a Case of Misjudged Expectations?

Julian Alvarez arrived at Atletico Madrid with enormous expectations after establishing himself as a decisive performer at Manchester City. His start to the 2025-26 season suggested he would meet them quickly, highlighted by a standout performance in the Madrid derby back in September.

Embed from Getty Images

As the season moves into January, the discussion around Alvarez has shifted. Some supporters feel his impact has cooled, while others argue his contribution remains strong within Atletico’s system. So what is the reality of his first campaign in La Liga?

A New Role, Not a New Player

At Manchester City, Alvarez operated in a fluid, attacking side built on sustained pressure and constant chance creation. At Atletico, his responsibilities are very different. Under Diego Simeone, structure, defensive work, and tactical discipline are non negotiable.

Rather than being one of several attacking stars, Alvarez often acts as Atletico’s primary reference point in attack. That shift alone changes how his performances should be judged.

Julian Alvarez: The Numbers Explained in Context

By early January, Alvarez has made 18 La Liga appearances, scoring 7 goals and providing 3 assists. While those figures may not place him among the league’s top scorers, they remain solid, particularly when viewed through the lens of Atletico’s playing style.

His efficiency in front of goal has remained consistent, and his involvement in build up play is reflected in his chance creation and key passing numbers. These are not the statistics of a player struggling to adapt, but of one adjusting to a more demanding and restrictive system.

Why the Narrative Around Julian Alvarez has changed

Much of the current debate stems from inflated expectations. Early season form created the impression that Alvarez would deliver consistently explosive numbers. When that did not continue at the same pace, frustration followed.

However, Atletico are not built to overwhelm opponents with goals. Matches are often tight, margins are small, and attacking players are expected to contribute without constant freedom.

In that environment, consistency often replaces spectacle.

Contribution Beyond Goals

Alvarez’s influence extends beyond the scoreline. His pressing, off the ball movement, and ability to link midfield and attack are central to Atletico’s approach. These aspects rarely dominate highlight reels but remain vital to the team’s overall balance.

Modern forwards are increasingly evaluated on involvement rather than output alone, and in that respect, Alvarez continues to meet the demands placed on him.

Final Assessment

Julian Alvarez’s debut season at Atletico Madrid may not be spectacular, but it is far from disappointing. He remains productive, tactically disciplined, and influential in key phases of play.

Rather than a decline, this campaign reflects adaptation to a new league, a new role, and a new tactical identity. The numbers suggest a player still contributing meaningfully, even if the spotlight has dimmed slightly.

For Atletico and Alvarez alike, patience may be the most important ingredient as this partnership continues to develop.